+8
mac
Detlef
Violet
Auras
Native spirit
zerdini
Knight of Albion
SpiritVoices
12 posters
Silver Birch.
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°1
Silver Birch.
Is it possible that the well known guide Silver Birch has returned again?
Knight of Albion- Member
Number of posts : 568
Location : Glastonbury, England
Registration date : 2013-12-18
- Post n°2
Re: Silver Birch.
Why do you say that?
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°3
Re: Silver Birch.
A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
zerdini- Member
Number of posts : 611
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2011-01-28
- Post n°4
Re: Silver Birch.
SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Silver Birch stated quite emphatically that he would not return again through another medium once his work through his medium (Barbanell) was done.
Native spirit- Member
Number of posts : 887
Registration date : 2011-02-04
- Post n°5
Re: Silver Birch.
i think for many young mediums they always feel better by saying the have had contact with someone well known, i know of one case where someone said that michael jackson was her guide
Namaste
Namaste
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°6
Re: Silver Birch.
Thank you for your confirmation,Zerdini.zerdini wrote:SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Silver Birch stated quite emphatically that he would not return again through another medium once his work through his medium (Barbanell) was done.
Much obliged.....
Auras- Member
Number of posts : 2027
Age : 25
Location : United Kingdom, Liverpool.
Registration date : 2012-05-06
- Post n°7
Re: Silver Birch.
SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Spirit can lie as we do.
There is obviously more than one silver birch in the world of spirit. But a good chance of being the famous guide everyone knows.
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°8
Re: Silver Birch.
There you are,Auras....must admit though,I haven't come across another SB, mainly reason being, the real SB is too well known.....Auras wrote:SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Spirit can lie as we do.
There is obviously more than one silver birch in the world of spirit. But a good chance of being the famous guide everyone knows.
I don't think that user name will ever be copied....
Auras- Member
Number of posts : 2027
Age : 25
Location : United Kingdom, Liverpool.
Registration date : 2012-05-06
- Post n°9
Re: Silver Birch.
SpiritVoices wrote:There you are,Auras....must admit though,I haven't come across another SB, mainly reason being, the real SB is too well known.....Auras wrote:SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Spirit can lie as we do.
There is obviously more than one silver birch in the world of spirit. But a good chance of being the famous guide everyone knows.
I don't think that user name will ever be copied....
Sorry about my last statement. I got the impression I was being rude.
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°10
Re: Silver Birch.
You weren't being rude at all,Auras....
I like your way of thinking and you add freshness to the topic.
Do you realise how you have changed over the last few months?
You are a remarkable young man now....
We are proud to have you on the site....
Back to Silver Birch....
What I am curious about why should such an elevated spirit such as he is,contact someone out of the blue or am I being impolite?
She is a lovely lady so how do we know his connection with her is not impossible?
One of those puzzles that will be not solved.....
I like your way of thinking and you add freshness to the topic.
Do you realise how you have changed over the last few months?
You are a remarkable young man now....
We are proud to have you on the site....
Back to Silver Birch....
What I am curious about why should such an elevated spirit such as he is,contact someone out of the blue or am I being impolite?
She is a lovely lady so how do we know his connection with her is not impossible?
One of those puzzles that will be not solved.....
Auras- Member
Number of posts : 2027
Age : 25
Location : United Kingdom, Liverpool.
Registration date : 2012-05-06
- Post n°11
Re: Silver Birch.
Thanks, Joanie.SpiritVoices wrote:You weren't being rude at all,Auras....
I like your way of thinking and you add freshness to the topic.
Do you realise how you have changed over the last few months?
You are a remarkable young man now....
We are proud to have you on the site....
Back to Silver Birch....
What I am curious about why should such an elevated spirit such as he is,contact someone out of the blue or am I being impolite?
She is a lovely lady so how do we know his connection with her is not impossible?
One of those puzzles that will be not solved.....
Is it really him though? Spirit have the ability to impersonate others so?
Violet- Admin
Number of posts : 24568
Location : UK
Registration date : 2009-02-15
- Post n°12
Re: Silver Birch.
It's an interesting thought isn't it that a guide could guide more than one person/come through to more than one person, reach out to the masses through more than one person, why wouldn't they? Hmmmmm....
Just when the caterpillar thought the world was over, it became a butterfly.
Detlef- Member
Number of posts : 923
Age : 76
Location : Australia
Registration date : 2010-09-25
- Post n°13
Re: Silver Birch.
It shouldn't be difficult to make contact with the entity called Silver Birch or what ever the name was, if someone claims a certain writing was from this entity, that is something different.SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Further, any entity we contact can make claims, who and what they are, it is then up to the individual to verify this claim, or just leave it as a possibility. Sure anything is possible nothing is certain.
If we come across of some kind of material, it does not matter what name is attached to it, we simply can read it if we like and see if it has any value for us. We have to decide not the name attached to it.
mac- Member
Number of posts : 4147
Age : 77
Location : Heart of England
Job/hobbies : retired
Registration date : 2010-04-23
- Post n°14
Re: Silver Birch.
Silver Birch communicated through a medium whose work in promoting Spiritualism was unique and went on for many years - the details can readily be found online.
SB said he'd chosen his medium-to-be long before that mediumship became evident. SB also said that he would never return to work with another instrument. Silver Birch's work, and his association with Maurice Barbanell in this world, came to an end when that man passed over.
Those like myself who know about their association, how it shaped the Spiritualist movement and who are constantly inspired by SB's simple teachings are unlikely to heed the claims of wannabe mediums; mediums who appear to believe they have an association with SB.
Of course there are no rules or laws that constrain a spirit communicator to just one medium but when a spiritually-elevated spirit declares he will not return, I'm given to accept what that spirit said. But, then, I'm a dyed-in-the-wool Modern Spiritualist who is greatly influenced by SB.
SB said he'd chosen his medium-to-be long before that mediumship became evident. SB also said that he would never return to work with another instrument. Silver Birch's work, and his association with Maurice Barbanell in this world, came to an end when that man passed over.
Those like myself who know about their association, how it shaped the Spiritualist movement and who are constantly inspired by SB's simple teachings are unlikely to heed the claims of wannabe mediums; mediums who appear to believe they have an association with SB.
Of course there are no rules or laws that constrain a spirit communicator to just one medium but when a spiritually-elevated spirit declares he will not return, I'm given to accept what that spirit said. But, then, I'm a dyed-in-the-wool Modern Spiritualist who is greatly influenced by SB.
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°15
Re: Silver Birch.
SB said he'd chosen his medium-to-be long before that mediumship became evident. SB also said that he would never return to work with another instrument. Silver Birch's work, and his association with Maurice Barbanell in this world, came to an end when that man passed over.
Is there a quote stating that,Mac?
Just for proof is all.
Is there a quote stating that,Mac?
Just for proof is all.
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°16
Re: Silver Birch.
If we come across of some kind of material, it does not matter what name is attached to it, we simply can read it if we like and see if it has any value for us. We have to decide not the name attached to it.Detlef wrote:It shouldn't be difficult to make contact with the entity called Silver Birch or what ever the name was, if someone claims a certain writing was from this entity, that is something different.SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Further, any entity we contact can make claims, who and what they are, it is then up to the individual to verify this claim, or just leave it as a possibility. Sure anything is possible nothing is certain.
If we come across of some kind of material, it does not matter what name is attached to it, we simply can read it if we like and see if it has any value for us. We have to decide not the name attached to it.
Good thinking,Detlef...The most important fact of all.
SB invited questions about what the spirit world was like. He gave a very good account of it.....One question was about transplants of organs.
SB answered by answering that we know the date of birth and death before we incarnate into our life. Now what does that say to you?
mac- Member
Number of posts : 4147
Age : 77
Location : Heart of England
Job/hobbies : retired
Registration date : 2010-04-23
- Post n°17
Re: Silver Birch.
What's publicly known about Silver Birch comes from transcripts of sittings involving Mr Barbanell. Those transcripts have been compiled into books by a number of authors and what he said about his association with Maurice Barbanell etc may be found there.
I lost my library of SB books after I lent them out to group members, foolishly expecting they would be returned. I am, therefore, unable to provide verbatim details of what Silver Birch said.
I lost my library of SB books after I lent them out to group members, foolishly expecting they would be returned. I am, therefore, unable to provide verbatim details of what Silver Birch said.
SpiritVoices- Member
Number of posts : 13312
Location : UK
Job/hobbies : Retired
Registration date : 2010-12-17
- Post n°18
Re: Silver Birch.
Fair enough,Mac. Lot to remember anyway....lent my book out too...still waiting for it to be returned.
Wisa'ka- Member
Number of posts : 285
Registration date : 2012-03-26
- Post n°19
Re: Silver Birch.
SpiritVoices wrote:Is it possible that the well known guide Silver Birch has returned again?
Oh yeah, I seen him in Harrah's Casino down in NC counting cards.
Why don't you let go of this illusion of yours regarding us as fantasy folk?
Skye2- Newbie
- Number of posts : 19
Registration date : 2014-04-11
- Post n°20
Re: Silver Birch.
Zerdini,zerdini wrote:SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Silver Birch stated quite emphatically that he would not return again through another medium once his work through his medium (Barbanell) was done.
Am I right in saying that Silver Birch was not actually an indian?
Skye2- Newbie
- Number of posts : 19
Registration date : 2014-04-11
- Post n°21
Re: Silver Birch.
SpiritVoices wrote:A very good medium on another site,I cannot give her name,has stated that she has had contact with Silver Birch....Very briefly but the name given to her by the contact was Silver Birch.
Joan,
I imagine there are as many spirit entities called Silver Birch, much like there is a fair few number of Red Clouds. And, those spirit entities of a Chinese influence whom may share the name of a well known person.
Last edited by Skye2 on Fri Apr 18, 2014 9:14 pm; edited 1 time in total
RavenMoon- Member
Number of posts : 585
Location : wishing to be somewhere serene and peacfull
Job/hobbies : fulltime and lots of interests
Registration date : 2012-05-06
- Post n°22
Re: Silver Birch.
Unfortunely Joanie is awaiting the legendary B T to rehook up her internet which will be next week.... when I am sure she will be back
with quite a force to answer your "responses & remarks".. May your god go with you all.....
with quite a force to answer your "responses & remarks".. May your god go with you all.....
Auras- Member
Number of posts : 2027
Age : 25
Location : United Kingdom, Liverpool.
Registration date : 2012-05-06
- Post n°23
Re: Silver Birch.
I don't know what to say now.... Why did he decide not to speak a medium ever again? was there a valid reason?
Skye2- Newbie
- Number of posts : 19
Registration date : 2014-04-11
- Post n°24
Re: Silver Birch.
Thank you Ravenmoon. I'm sure she will beRavenMoon wrote:Unfortunely Joanie is awaiting the legendary B T to rehook up her internet which will be next week.... when I am sure she will be back
with quite a force to answer your "responses & remarks".. May your god go with you all.....
RavenMoon- Member
Number of posts : 585
Location : wishing to be somewhere serene and peacfull
Job/hobbies : fulltime and lots of interests
Registration date : 2012-05-06
- Post n°25
Re: Silver Birch.
been rather quiet without her.... so be warned.. 22 April... she'll be back..